Blog · 4 min read

How to Read Fence Reviews Before You Hire

Regal Fencing Father-and-son fence company, Aurora, CO Published , updated
Rail side of a new cedar dog-ear fence mid-install, showing three rails and post spacing

Read past the star rating. Look for recent, specific reviews that describe a project like yours, and watch for patterns in comments about communication, posts, gates and cleanup. Regal Fencing held 4.5 stars from 93 Google reviews in November 2026, and the details in them tell you more than the score does.

A fence can look great on installation day and still show problems after the first hard wind, wet snow or shift in Colorado soil. That is why fence reviews deserve more than a glance at a star rating.

The most useful feedback tells you how a contractor communicates, handles details and responds when conditions change. Reviews cannot replace an estimate in person, but they help you ask better questions.

What should fence reviews tell you?

The best reviews are specific. A five star rating is encouraging, but a comment about sturdy posts, protected landscaping, a met HOA requirement or a gate repaired correctly gives you more to work with.

Note the type of work mentioned. A contractor may have strong feedback for chain link repair and fewer examples of horizontal wood, board on board privacy fences or commercial installs. That does not rule them out, but it should guide your estimate conversation.

Reviews also show whether a company listens. A family replacing a leaning fence may care most about pets and privacy, and a commercial site may need controlled access. The contractor should not offer the same solution to every property.

Why read beyond the star rating?

A high average matters, but it is not the whole story. Read a range of recent reviews, including the middle ratings and the occasional critical one. Every contractor can face a late delivery, bad weather or a surprise under an old fence line, and what matters is how the company handled it.

Look for patterns in comments about communication. Customers remember whether someone returned calls, explained schedule changes and arrived as promised. One of our reviewers, Samantha P., wrote that "James communicated with me the whole time."

Consider timing. Recent reviews give a better picture of current crews and service than a large number from long ago. Older reviews still count when they mention how the fence has held up.

Long run of new cedar privacy fence with a flat top cap and a double drive gate with black T-hinges
Cedar privacy fence, flat top cap, double drive gate with black T-hinges

Which details point to quality workmanship?

Strong reviews mention things homeowners may not know to inspect. Watch for straight lines, sturdy posts, secure gates, even spacing, clean cuts and tidy transitions on slopes.

For wood, look for mentions of quality lumber, staining and consistent board placement. For vinyl, look for stable posts and panels that stay aligned. For chain link, look for comments on tension, terminal posts and gates.

In the Denver metro, wind and freeze and thaw make the foundation important. Repeated praise for solid construction is a meaningful signal. Cleanup counts too, and Tim D. wrote that our crew "swept the sidewalk and even the street."

Which reviews match your project?

The most relevant review may not be the most enthusiastic one. If you need to replace a storm damaged fence shared with a neighbor, look for customers who faced the same thing. If you live in an HOA, reviews that mention design approvals and compliant styles help more than a broad endorsement.

A custom project deserves extra attention. Read for mentions of design guidance, material recommendations and a willingness to explain options. A good fence company balances appearance, maintenance, privacy and budget instead of pushing the most expensive material.

Small jobs are worth checking too. Ulises A. wrote that he "called 20 companies no one wanted to come due to this being a small project," and that we gave a quote and did the work.

How should you interpret negative fence reviews?

Read them carefully. Ask whether the concern is specific and whether it repeats. One complaint about a scheduling conflict is different from several customers describing missed appointments, unfinished work or damaged property.

Then read the company's response. A professional response is direct, respectful and focused on fixing the issue. Defensive language or blame shifting is a warning sign, though no single review tells the complete story.

Some bad experiences are not signs of poor craftsmanship. Material availability, permits, weather and neighbors all affect a timeline. The better question is whether the contractor set realistic expectations and spoke up when the plan changed.

How do you use reviews to prepare for your estimate?

Turn what you read into questions. If customers praise a company's gate work, ask how the gate will be framed and placed in your yard. If they mention communication, ask who your point of contact will be.

Bring practical information. That includes your property lines if known, HOA guidelines, preferred style, pet or child safety needs, and any spots with drainage, slopes, utility marks or tight access.

A dependable contractor explains what the estimate includes, from demolition and disposal to posts, materials, gate hardware and cleanup. Ask about repair versus replacement if the old fence has limited damage.

What is a better standard than good reviews?

The goal is not just a contractor with positive feedback. It is one whose reviews describe the experience and result you want: a fence that fits the property and holds through the seasons.

At Regal Fencing, every estimate is a chance to understand the property before recommending anything. The visit is free and on site, and Jackson Vann gives a written price, usually the same day.

Read enough reviews to see the patterns, then trust your own conversation with the contractor. The right company makes the next steps clear and answers questions without pressure.

FAQ

What else do people ask?

4 questions, answered plainly

  1. What should I look for in fence company reviews?

    Look for specific details: sturdy posts, secure gates, straight lines, cleanup and clear communication. Reviews that describe a project like yours are the most useful.

  2. Are older reviews still useful?

    Yes, especially when they mention how the fence has held up over time. Recent reviews should carry more weight, because they reflect the company's current crews and service.

  3. Should one negative review rule out a contractor?

    No. Check whether the complaint is specific and whether it repeats across several reviews. Then read how the company responded.

  4. What are Regal Fencing's Google reviews?

    Regal Fencing held 4.5 stars from 93 Google reviews in November 2026. The details in those reviews say more than the score.

Keep reading

  • Cedar picture-frame privacy fence with pyramid-cut post tops on a new-build lot

    November 13, 2026

    Can You Install a Fence in Winter in Colorado?

    36 inches is the frost depth in the Aurora and Douglas County codes, and it is a design figure, not a winter ban. See what decides if a fence can go in now.

  • New cedar cap and trim privacy fence with a wide wood gate, black strap hinges and a drop latch

    November 10, 2026

    Colorado 811: What to Do Before You Build a Fence

    2 business days of notice is the law in Colorado, and Colorado 811 asks for 3. See what gets marked before a fence goes in and how our sprinkler line guarantee works.

  • Rail side of a new cedar dog-ear fence mid-install, showing three rails and post spacing

    November 8, 2026

    Is It Cheaper to Repair or Replace a Fence?

    1 or 2 damaged sections with solid posts is a repair. Posts failing along the whole line point to replacement. A 10 minute check tells you which fence you have.

Testimonials

What do customers say about Regal Fencing?

4.5 stars from 93 Google reviews. Quoted exactly as written.

  • I can’t recommend Regal fencing more. The entire process was smooth and James communicated with me the whole time. My new fence looks amazing. Thank you!

    Samantha P.Google review,
  • called 20 companies no one wanted to come due to this being a small project. This company gave us a quote and they did an excellent job. We will be replacing our entire fence with them soon. great work fair price and all around professionals

    Ulises A.Google review,
  • ... the crew was great to work with. Super conscientious communications. ... Theirs was a fair, reasonable price. Good quality wood and good attention to design, and good quality, solid construction.

    Sam B.Google review,
  • We went back with the metal posts instead of 4x4 cedar posts. The crew showed up on time with all the materials needed for the job. No running back and forth to Home Depot. ... The clean up is worth talking about, they swept the sidewalk and even the street.

    Tim D.Google review,
  • They were very clear in their communication, including helping me find solutions to unexpected findings when repairing my deck without increasing cost. The work they did on fence and deck was professional and solid. Everything feels much safer now.

    Frank R.Google review,

Read more reviews